Since 1998

In the shadow of the Sainte-Baume

Hear the cicadas? Breathe out, it’s summer.
Then Jean de Florette ends, and autumn comes, then winter.  That’s when you discover a different light in this lovely corner of Provence, by bike, but this time on the northern side of the Sainte-Baume: on the Plan d’Aups.  This is the D95.  It’s mid-morning, and you can feel the sun is right there, behind the Sainte-Baume.  Yet one question nags at you: will it peek above the ridge at its highest point, around 12:30pm? Let’s try to answer that below.
North-east aerial view of the Sainte-Baume (credit Google Earth).

Disclaimer

This educational article is aimed at readers who understand the notion of a cast shadow, and so the simple relationship between the height of an object, the height of the sun (= its angle with the horizon) and the length of the shadow.  This relationship is in fact called the tangent function in geometry.  But at worst, if you don’t quite understand what a tangent is, it doesn’t really matter, because any basic scientific calculator has a [tan] key that does the maths for you.

Notation

Angles will be expressed or understood in degrees, since we’re working in geography, rather than in radians as is traditionally the case in trigonometry.

Reminder

  • tangent: the ratio between the height of a right-angled triangle, vertical here, and its base, horizontal here.  In the case we’re interested in, the tangent ranges over [0, +∞].  In fact, it’s simply the ratio between the height of a tree and the length of its shadow on the ground!

Hands-on activity

The point of this topic is to predict the existence, at the limits, of favourable or unfavourable events in a cyclical phenomenon, when you know the situation at a given moment of the cycle.  The cyclist on the D95 is just one example.  But the same principle applies to finding out whether a house, a crop or solar panels will get sun all year round or not, and if not, during which time window the sun will be hidden.

The setting

The setting of the problem: the D95 running north of the Sainte-Baume (credit Google Earth). The Sainte-Baume is a mountain ridge about 11 km long and 2 km wide, in Provence, straddling the Bouches-du-Rhône (13) and the Var (83).  It runs ENE (East-North-East), so for most of the day it casts its shadow over the D95 road, in the Var, which runs parallel to it for several kilometres.

In summer it’s very hot in this hinterland swept by a hot, dry wind.  But the sun is then far too high above the horizon to give you any shade.  If you hike on its northern side, or ride the D95, you’ll inevitably think that come autumn, the Sainte-Baume’s shadow will reach far enough to give you a break, at least where the D95 runs close enough to the mountain.  In particular, you might wonder whether, at the winter solstice, when the sun is at its lowest above the horizon, a car parked by the D95 will be in the shade all day or not.  Cyclists may have a similar question about the road: will there be a time of day when the sun, though low, is high enough in the sky to dry the night dew off the road? If, like me, big nerd that I am, this interests you, then read on!

Statement of the problem

The longitude chosen for this study is the one shown in this image (credit Google Earth). Ok, you’re still here! So here’s the situation: at solar noon, i.e.  at its culmination point, on a certain day of the year, a date and time we’ll call date t, the sun casts the Sainte-Baume’s shadow to the north, while, at that particular longitude, the D95 runs practically at the foot of the mountain.
Thanks to these Google Earth shots, we can estimate the horizontal distance between the mountain’s summit and the D95.  Given the scale, this distance is 750 m.

The distance [B D95] is 750 m. From now on, I’ll call “the D95” the segment of the D95 crossing that longitude, not the whole road.

I don’t know about you, but three questions spring to my bubbling mind:

  1. how far horizontally is the shadow cast when the sun is at its lowest of the year but at its noon (= at its highest point in the sky)?
  2. is the D95 in the Sainte-Baume’s shadow all day that day?
  3. If so, on what date does the D95 enter “the dark”, and on what date does it come out of it?
These three questions are the statement of the problem.
We place ourselves at the winter solstice: that’s the second assumption of our problem.

Right, we won’t redo the whole calculation I already present in the article How do you calculate the height of the sun at time t, but if we still agree with the approximations below, we’ll borrow from that article an equation giving the sun’s height at its culmination point for any day of the year.  It’s handy, because from that angle we can calculate the horizontal distance at which the shadow of the mountain’s summit is cast on the ground.  Will this shadow cover the D95? Or won’t it reach it?

Chosen approximations

As I said in the article mentioned above, as always in nature, things aren’t perfect shapes, so to use the equation proven in the other topic, we’ll make the following approximations:

  1. the Earth’s orbit around the sun is considered circular.
  2. the Earth’s orbital speed is considered constant over the year, so that its polar angle is proportional to the day of the year.
  3. the Earth is considered spherical, with radius R.
  4. the origin of the Earth’s polar coordinates on its orbit, represented by θ=0, will be arbitrarily set at the boreal winter solstice, i.e.  20, 21 or 22 December depending on the year.

Longitudinal cross-section of the Sainte-Baume at 5°47’20.48”. With that agreed, we take the extended Law no.3, as seen here.

θ = h(t) = 90° - |λP| + tan-1(tan -ε .  cos(Q(t) - Q0)/365*360)
With λP = the latitude of point D, ε the tilt angle of the Earth on its ecliptic, i.e.  23°26’15", Q(t) - Q0 the number of days between the date we’re interested in and the winter solstice.  Oh! Handy: Q(t) = Q0, since we’re placing ourselves on the day the sun is lowest in the sky, and by definition that day is the winter solstice.  So we directly know the angle between the sun and the horizon, since it’s a limit case of this equation.

What a handy equation! It directly gives us the expression of the sun’s height at its culmination point, as a function of the day of the year.

Numerical value of θ at the winter solstice:
θ0 = 90° - 43°20’30" + -23°26’15" = 46°39’30" - 23°26’15" = 23°13’15"
Since we also know the height of the mountain ridge, i.e.  its altitude minus the altitude of the D95, we’ll use the tangent relationship of the right-angled triangle BSD to work out the length of the base [BD].

Calculating [BD]:
The definition of the tangent in a right-angled triangle, and its use in calculating the length of the shadow cast. In triangle BSD, seen in the longitudinal cross-section above, and sketched as the triangle alongside, we have:

[BD] = [BS] / tan θ
now
[BS] = alt(S) - alt(D95) = 1103 m - 713 m = 390 m
hence
[BD] = 390 / tan(23°13’) = 909 m

Answer to question 1 of the problem statement
At the winter solstice, and at the longitude considered in our problem, 5°47’20.48", the Sainte-Baume’s shadow is cast 909 m from the vertical of the ridge.
Answer to question 2 of the problem statement
Since the D95, at that longitude, is only 750 m from the ridge, it is in the shade at solar noon on the day of the winter solstice.
Answer to question 3 of the problem statement

There is indeed an entry date t1 into the shade and an exit date t2 from the shade, since at the winter solstice there are 909-750 = 159 m of shade north of the D95.  But what are these dates?
We need to take the problem the other way round: what value of the sun’s height θlimit = h(t1) = h(t2) would give a shadow [BD] exactly 750 m long? There must be two dates giving this result from the famous Law no.3.

[BD] = 750 m  <=>  390 / tan(θlimit) = 750 m, i.e.  θlimit = tan-1(390/750) = 27°28’28"
Now
θlimit = 90° - 43°20’30" + tan-1(tan(-23°26’15") .  cos( (Q(t) - Q0)/365*360 ))
from which we deduce
(Q(t) - Q0)/365*360 = cos-1( tan(90-θlimit-43°20’30") / tan(23°26’15"))
From which we deduce
|(Q(t) - Q0)/365*360| = 36.6°
That is
|(Q(t) - Q0)| = 37 days
That is, the date when the D95 enters the Sainte-Baume’s shadow at solar noon is 37 days before the winter solstice, and the exit date is symmetrically 37 days after.  Taking a winter solstice on 21 December, we get:
At this longitude, the D95 enters the shade on t1 = 14 November, and comes out of it on t2 = 27 January.

Careful, I insist: I’m only looking at solar noon, when the sun is due south.  Because in practice, this stretch of the D95 actually gets the winter sun around 2:30pm, when the sun is SSW and the ridge that was hiding it drops below 1000 m . . .

(1 view)
created Tuesday 18 November 2014
revised Wednesday 04 November 2026 by
Would you accept our confidentiality policy? It is about cookies and personal data...